• Home
  • Contact Me
Wednesday, May 31, 2023
Rana Safvi
  • Home
  • About
  • Book & Publication
  • Culture & Heritage
    • Our Cultural Heritage
    • Sufi saints
  • Food
  • Hazrat-E-Dilli
  • Rana’s Space
    • Walks & Talks
    • Rana’s Space
    • Sher o Sukhan
  • Travel

    Mausoleum of Shad-e (or Shadi) Mulk Aga in Shah e Zinda, Samarqand

    Mausoleum of Mahmud Pahlavon in Khiva, Uzbekistan

    The tomb of Baba Rukn al-Din Shirazi, Takht-i Fulad, Isfahan, Iran

    The Summer Mosque of the Arc in Khiva, Uzbekistan

    Shrine of Sheikh Zainuddin Bobo in Tashkent, Uzbekistan

    The Madrasas ( educational institutions) of Ulugh Beg

    The Madrasas ( educational institutions) of Ulugh Beg

    Dargah of Sheikh Raju Qattal in Khuldabad, Maharashtra

    Dargah of Sheikh Raju Qattal in Khuldabad, Maharashtra

    AkshayVat in Allahabad/ Prayagraj

    AkshayVat in Allahabad/ Prayagraj

    Helical stepwell in Pavagadh area of Gujarat

    Mysore Silk and Tipu Sultan

    Mysore Silk and Tipu Sultan

    Lord Buddha statue in Chandigarh Museum

    Akbar’s Inscription in The Ranakpur Jain Temple

    Neelkanth Temple in Kumbhalgarh

    Neelkanth Temple in Kumbhalgarh

    Vijai Stambh in Chittorgarh Fort

    The importance of River Yamuna in Vrindavan

    The importance of River Yamuna in Vrindavan

    Tajuddin Baba of Nagpur or Shahenshah-e Haft-e Aqleem Hazrat Baba Tajuddin

    Tajuddin Baba of Nagpur or Shahenshah-e Haft-e Aqleem Hazrat Baba Tajuddin

    Shri Niwas or the House of Mirrors in Jaipur’s City Palace

    Shri Niwas or the House of Mirrors in Jaipur’s City Palace

    Kanishka statue in Mathura museum

    Kanishka statue in Mathura museum

    Shahji ka Mandir, Vrindavan

    Shahji ka Mandir, Vrindavan

    Gopinath Mandir in Vrindavan

    Gopinath Mandir in Vrindavan

    Trending Tags

    • Contact Me
    No Result
    View All Result
    • Home
    • About
    • Book & Publication
    • Culture & Heritage
      • Our Cultural Heritage
      • Sufi saints
    • Food
    • Hazrat-E-Dilli
    • Rana’s Space
      • Walks & Talks
      • Rana’s Space
      • Sher o Sukhan
    • Travel

      Mausoleum of Shad-e (or Shadi) Mulk Aga in Shah e Zinda, Samarqand

      Mausoleum of Mahmud Pahlavon in Khiva, Uzbekistan

      The tomb of Baba Rukn al-Din Shirazi, Takht-i Fulad, Isfahan, Iran

      The Summer Mosque of the Arc in Khiva, Uzbekistan

      Shrine of Sheikh Zainuddin Bobo in Tashkent, Uzbekistan

      The Madrasas ( educational institutions) of Ulugh Beg

      The Madrasas ( educational institutions) of Ulugh Beg

      Dargah of Sheikh Raju Qattal in Khuldabad, Maharashtra

      Dargah of Sheikh Raju Qattal in Khuldabad, Maharashtra

      AkshayVat in Allahabad/ Prayagraj

      AkshayVat in Allahabad/ Prayagraj

      Helical stepwell in Pavagadh area of Gujarat

      Mysore Silk and Tipu Sultan

      Mysore Silk and Tipu Sultan

      Lord Buddha statue in Chandigarh Museum

      Akbar’s Inscription in The Ranakpur Jain Temple

      Neelkanth Temple in Kumbhalgarh

      Neelkanth Temple in Kumbhalgarh

      Vijai Stambh in Chittorgarh Fort

      The importance of River Yamuna in Vrindavan

      The importance of River Yamuna in Vrindavan

      Tajuddin Baba of Nagpur or Shahenshah-e Haft-e Aqleem Hazrat Baba Tajuddin

      Tajuddin Baba of Nagpur or Shahenshah-e Haft-e Aqleem Hazrat Baba Tajuddin

      Shri Niwas or the House of Mirrors in Jaipur’s City Palace

      Shri Niwas or the House of Mirrors in Jaipur’s City Palace

      Kanishka statue in Mathura museum

      Kanishka statue in Mathura museum

      Shahji ka Mandir, Vrindavan

      Shahji ka Mandir, Vrindavan

      Gopinath Mandir in Vrindavan

      Gopinath Mandir in Vrindavan

      Trending Tags

      • Contact Me
      No Result
      View All Result
      Rana Safvi
      No Result
      View All Result

      Monumental mistakes

      inMedieval Indian History, Rana's Space
      0

      Hurt Heritage: Preventing Monumental mistakes
      Without Architecture, we cannot remember…”
      – John Ruskin, Seven Lamps of Architecture

      When The British occupied Shahjahanabad, or Old Delhi as it is now known, they remodeled the city as well as the Mughal Red Fort to suit their convenience and mood: as many as 80% of the buildings inside Red Fort were demolished to make way for military barracks. Mansions and havelis were demolished to make way for broader, new roads so that they had easy access for defensive purposes, in case the populace decided to ‘rebel’ against them again.

      Perhaps all may have got demolished but for a horrified Lord Canning who tried to preserve our heritage.

      The Archaeological Survey of India (ASI) was formed in 1861 by a statute passed into law by Lord Canning with Sir Alexander Cunningham as its first Archaeological Surveyor to excavate and conserve India’s ancient built heritage.

      In 1904, a Cambridge classics scholar who was the Director General of ASI, formulated THE ANCIENT MONUMENTS PRESERVATION ACT 1904 (modified on 1st September 1949) for the preservation of ancient monuments. Since much damage had already been done to India’s rich built heritage due to ignorance, greed and neglect, controls and checks were put in place ‘for exercise of control over traffic in antiquities and over excavation in certain places’. Checks were put in place for ‘mining, quarrying, excavating, blasting and other operations of a like nature’.
      Its aim was to preserve monuments as archaeological ruin on an ‘as is where is’ basis as a simple act of indirect conservation and regular maintenance.
      Sir John Marshall also drew up a conservation manual in 1922, which combined the best conservation practices from all over the world, adapted to Indian context and was one of the most comprehensive documents written on conservation at that time.
      The job of the ASI, which comes under the Ministry of Culture, is to protect the cultural heritage of our nation.
      The Ancient Monuments and Archaelogical Sites and Remains (Amendment and Validation) Act, 2010 was passed with provisions to safeguard and protect ancient monuments and antiquities of India as well as regulate all construction activity around the monuments.

      It specified a ‘prohibited area’, which meant that no construction activity (erection or a building, including any addition or extension thereto either vertically or horizontally) could take place within 100 metres in all directions of a monument. There was another regulated area, which was 200 metres further beyond the prohibited area where persons may undertake construction, reconstruction, repairs and renovation but only after obtaining permission from the Competent Authority on the recommendation of National Monuments Authority.

      Prof Ali Nadeem Rezavi of Centre of Advanced Studies, Dept of History, AMU, Aligarh says, “Any tinkering with its provisions, especially the laws around its maintenance and prohibitions in allowing any encroachment or building around it would create loopholes to undo the watertight protection which has been provided for them by law. Once you allow constructions around it, the monuments can be easily suffocated. This we have already been witnessing in heritage cities like Delhi where encroachments have drained out the life of a number of monuments.”
      He further bemoans the destruction of many medieval monuments such as kos minars, dams, barrages and bridges in the path of development.
      The world heritage sites are listed as category A monuments while other ticketed monuments are category B. The most vulnerable are the category C, around which dense habitation has taken place. In many cases the monument is all but stifled as it’s surrounded by unchecked construction.
      A few weeks ago, I had shared a coloured lithograph from Sir Syed Ahmed’s 1847 seminal work on Delhi monuments: Asar us Sanadeed on twitter and Facebook with the caption, ‘Can you identify this monument?’ Nobody could.
      The lithograph showed the beautiful octagonal tomb of Mubarak Shah Sayyid, the second ruler of Sayyid dynasty of Delhi who died in A.D. 1434 and was buried there in an area named after him, Mubarakpur Kotla. However, sometime in the past century people from neighbouring villages occupied this place. Today it is smothered by multiple storeyed houses on all sides and barely has room to breathe.
      If I had found that with great difficulty, the search for its companion mosque was even worse. It’s now a dump-yard which one has to approach through a narrow passage in one of the tenements surrounding it. One jumps onto a rubbish heap to get inside as its access has been blocked on all sides by construction.
      There are numerous other heritage sites, which are already under threat or have been destroyed when stringent rules were in place. What will happen if these are removed to accommodate future construction?
      Ever since I remember I have been fascinated by monuments, ruins, and the stones do speak to me with tales of their past glory and drama and as a heritage lover, the news that a note has been sent by the Culture Ministry to the cabinet with a proposal to amend the 2010 Act disturbs me to the core. I realised I am not alone as many share my concerns.
      Priyank Gupta a junior research fellow in Department of Ancient History, Culture & Archaeology, Gurukula Kangari Vishwavidhyalaya,
      Haridwar says, “It’s going to disturb the water table of the land, it will affect ancient sewage system of a monument. Ancient foundation, which was built of wood, will be most affected. Continuous vibration of heavy vehicles will affect its strength.”
      When I asked eminent historian Prof Irfan Habib, he replied, “ This is against all recognized rules of conservation and it should be opposed by all people who want to protect our heritage.”
      One of the monuments which is said to be affected by a proposed elevated road within the prohibited area is Akbar’s tomb in Sikandra, Agra
      Syed Jamal Hasan who recently retired as Director Achaeology from ASI says that “Akbar’s tomb in Sikandra has monumental importance as it was here that we see the first example of a minaret in North India in the Gateway built by Jahangir. This was later successfully copied by Shah Jahan.”
      Not only will the proposed elevated road hide the tomb’s gateway but have long term damage to the structure during construction and later because of traffic within the 100 m prohibited zone.
      I agree we need development but does our future have to be at the cost of our past?

      Share this:

      • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
      • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)

      Related Posts

      Hazrat-E-Dilli

      dargah Asar sharif in Delhi ”s Jama Masjid

      by Rana Safvi
      May 30, 2023
      Nawab Wajid Ali Shah
      Medieval Indian History

      Nawab Wajid Ali Shah

      by Rana Safvi
      May 16, 2023
      Dargah of Sheikh Raju Qattal in Khuldabad, Maharashtra
      sufi saints

      Dargah of Sheikh Raju Qattal in Khuldabad, Maharashtra

      by Rana Safvi
      May 15, 2023
      Leave Comment
      Twitter Facebook Instagram Youtube
      Rana Safvi

      Come, explore and fall in love the Beauties of Delhi (Dilli ki Ranaiya’n) and the World with me, Rana Safvi

      I have a masters in medieval history from the prestigious Centre for Advanced Studies, Dept. of History, AMU. A firm believer in our Ganga Jamuni Tehzeeb, I am passionate about gaining and sharing knowledge and these days I am doing it via the social media platform.

      Browse by Category

      Currently Playing

      © 2018 Rana Safvi - A blog Exploring Ganga Jamuni Tehzeeb of India, website handcrafted by Abu Sufiyan.

      No Result
      View All Result
      • Home
      • About
      • Book & Publication
      • Culture & Heritage
        • Our Cultural Heritage
        • Sufi saints
      • Food
      • Hazrat-E-Dilli
      • Rana’s Space
        • Walks & Talks
        • Rana’s Space
        • Sher o Sukhan
      • Travel
      • Contact Me

      © 2018 Rana Safvi - A blog Exploring Ganga Jamuni Tehzeeb of India, website handcrafted by Abu Sufiyan.