• Home
  • Contact Me
Tuesday, May 17, 2022
Rana Safvi
  • Home
  • About
  • Book & Publication
  • Culture & Heritage
    • Our Cultural Heritage
    • Sufi saints
  • Food
  • Hazrat-E-Dilli
  • Rana’s Space
    • Walks & Talks
    • Rana’s Space
    • Sher o Sukhan
  • Travel
    Samode Palace near Jaipur

    Samode Palace near Jaipur

    Char Bangla Temple, Azimganj, West Bengal

    Char Bangla Temple, Azimganj, West Bengal

    Was BNR House in Garden Reach Kolkata Wajid Ali Shah’s Sultan Mahal?

    Was BNR House in Garden Reach Kolkata Wajid Ali Shah’s Sultan Mahal?

    Sarai Nur Mahal in Punjab

    Sarai Nur Mahal in Punjab

    The Moorish Mosque in Kapurthala, Punjab

    The Moorish Mosque in Kapurthala, Punjab

    Tomb of Haji Jamal in Nakodar, Punjab

    Tomb of Haji Jamal in Nakodar, Punjab

    The Tomb of Ustad Muhammad Mumin Hussain in Nakodar, Punjab

    The Tomb of Ustad Muhammad Mumin Hussain in Nakodar, Punjab

    The Hathikhana or Khan e Dauran’s estate in Agra

    The Hathikh ana or Khan e Dauran’s estate in Agra

    The Hathikhana or Khan e Dauran’s estate in Agra

    The Hathikhana or Khan e Dauran’s estate in Agra

    The Hathikhana or Khan e Dauran’s estate in Agra

    The Hathikhana or Khan e Dauran’s estate in Agra

    The Gajantak incarnation of Lord Shiva on the Outer Walls of Kalinjar Fort

    Amravati Ashram in Chitrakoot

    Mrigdhara in Kalinjar Fort, Bundelkhand

    Mrigdhara in Kalinjar Fort, Bundelkhand

    Kal Bhairava in Sati Ansuyya ghat in Chitrakoot

    Kal Bhairava in Sati Ansuyya ghat in Chitrakoot

    Kal Bhairava in Kalinjar Fort

    Kal Bhairava in Kalinjar Fort

    Chaturbhuj Temple, Orchha

    Chaturbhuj Temple, Orchha

    Dandeshwar group of Temples near Almora

    Dandeshwar group of Temples near Almora

    Moti Bagh Mosque, Agra

    Moti Bagh Mosque, Agra

    The art of khatamband or decorative ceilings of Kashmir

    The art of khatamband or decorative ceilings of Kashmir

    Rozabal in Srinagar, Kashmir

    Rozabal in Srinagar, Kashmir

    Trending Tags

    • Contact Me
    No Result
    View All Result
    • Home
    • About
    • Book & Publication
    • Culture & Heritage
      • Our Cultural Heritage
      • Sufi saints
    • Food
    • Hazrat-E-Dilli
    • Rana’s Space
      • Walks & Talks
      • Rana’s Space
      • Sher o Sukhan
    • Travel
      Samode Palace near Jaipur

      Samode Palace near Jaipur

      Char Bangla Temple, Azimganj, West Bengal

      Char Bangla Temple, Azimganj, West Bengal

      Was BNR House in Garden Reach Kolkata Wajid Ali Shah’s Sultan Mahal?

      Was BNR House in Garden Reach Kolkata Wajid Ali Shah’s Sultan Mahal?

      Sarai Nur Mahal in Punjab

      Sarai Nur Mahal in Punjab

      The Moorish Mosque in Kapurthala, Punjab

      The Moorish Mosque in Kapurthala, Punjab

      Tomb of Haji Jamal in Nakodar, Punjab

      Tomb of Haji Jamal in Nakodar, Punjab

      The Tomb of Ustad Muhammad Mumin Hussain in Nakodar, Punjab

      The Tomb of Ustad Muhammad Mumin Hussain in Nakodar, Punjab

      The Hathikhana or Khan e Dauran’s estate in Agra

      The Hathikh ana or Khan e Dauran’s estate in Agra

      The Hathikhana or Khan e Dauran’s estate in Agra

      The Hathikhana or Khan e Dauran’s estate in Agra

      The Hathikhana or Khan e Dauran’s estate in Agra

      The Hathikhana or Khan e Dauran’s estate in Agra

      The Gajantak incarnation of Lord Shiva on the Outer Walls of Kalinjar Fort

      Amravati Ashram in Chitrakoot

      Mrigdhara in Kalinjar Fort, Bundelkhand

      Mrigdhara in Kalinjar Fort, Bundelkhand

      Kal Bhairava in Sati Ansuyya ghat in Chitrakoot

      Kal Bhairava in Sati Ansuyya ghat in Chitrakoot

      Kal Bhairava in Kalinjar Fort

      Kal Bhairava in Kalinjar Fort

      Chaturbhuj Temple, Orchha

      Chaturbhuj Temple, Orchha

      Dandeshwar group of Temples near Almora

      Dandeshwar group of Temples near Almora

      Moti Bagh Mosque, Agra

      Moti Bagh Mosque, Agra

      The art of khatamband or decorative ceilings of Kashmir

      The art of khatamband or decorative ceilings of Kashmir

      Rozabal in Srinagar, Kashmir

      Rozabal in Srinagar, Kashmir

      Trending Tags

      • Contact Me
      No Result
      View All Result
      Rana Safvi
      No Result
      View All Result

      Pitfalls of erasing Mughals from Indian history

      The State, especially in a democracy, cannot play a partisan role without the danger of alienating entire communities

      inBook and Publication
      0

      A few days ago, an article in the Pakistani newspaperThe Dawnwas being shared on social media – “Why is the great philosopher Kautilya not part of Pakistan’s historical consciousness?”

      It ended with: “If Pakistan is to come out of its tortuous identity crisis, it needs to accept its non-Muslim history as its own. Recognising someone as important as Chanakya will have to be part of the long process.”

      Many in India endorsed this, as they should.

      Ironically, a few days later we were told that history textbooks in Maharashtra had all but deleted mention of Mughal (read Muslim) and Western history from its syllabi, claiming it’s irrelevant. It is now Maharashtra-centric and the role of Shivaji and his family has been expanded.

      I have not seen the textbook; just the table of content shown inTheQuint. Do the Ahmadnagar and Bijapur kingdoms find mention, which would fall into present day Maharashtra? Do they mention the legendary Chand Bibi who ruled Ahmednagar? A contemporary of Elizabeth I, she ruled over a huge area and was one of the few rulers who defeated Akbar’s army.

      In fact, Shivaji’s grandfather, Maloji Bhonsale, was a general in the army. He had no children despite many years of marriage and finally went to a Sufi saint named Shah Sharif, with whose blessings he got two sons, named Shahji and Sharifji.

      Shahji too served in the Ahmadnagar army under Malik Ambar, an Ethiopian slave who rose to become a general in the army due to his brilliance in strategic and administrative abilities. He was a pioneer of guerrilla warfare and this strategy was later adopted by Shivaji.

      India has been home to a diverse, multicultural, multiplural society which has shaped its society and people. In a multi-cultural country, where there are different shared experiences for different groups, it is the state which has to play the role of the unifier.

      To glorify one we don’t need to belittle the other. That is the act of a very insecure people.

       

      The state, especially in a democracy, cannot play a partisan role without the danger of alienating entire communities. We cannot deny or wipeout 800 years from our country’s history for they have made us what we are today.

      “Except perhaps the most primitive, every society includes diversity, and not all its members hold identical views on all areas of life,” writes Bhikhu Parikh inComposite Culture in a Multicultural Society.

      When writing and teaching history, sociology and other subjects which deal with the past, we cannot remove or ignore entire chunks from it. No ruler or incident lived in isolation. Particular events were shaped because of reaction to others and as such teaching of accurate history is important.

      What then is history?

      When writing history for present and future generations what is the responsibility of the historian?

      Is “history the lie commonly agreed upon,” as Voltaire said, or is “accuracy a duty and not a virtue” according to AE Housman?

      There is no doubt that every historian will analyse historical events within his/her own knowledge, existing bias and social context but that it should be accurate is a given.

      We cannot simply change the outcome of a war because we want to belittle one protagonist and celebrate the other – as has been done in Rajasthan University.

      To glorify one we don’t need to belittle the other. That is the act of a very insecure people. The Battle of Haldighati was a battle between two brave rulers. Akbar’s army was led by the Rajput king Man Singh and Maharana Pratap’s general was the Afghan general Hakim Khan Sur. Why are we trying to reduce it to a battle between rulers belonging to different religions?

      History is taught in schools because it introduces young minds to events of the past so they may learn from it. By removing references to events such as the French Revolution, Greek philosophy and the American War of Independence which shaped the world, we are doing a disservice to our students. In a world of growing awareness and knowledge we seek to curtail their knowledge.

      By not teaching them about Sultan Raziya, the first female monarch of South Asia, we take away the sense of pride. History should be taught for its impact on the future so we may take lesson from it.

      By teaching selective history we also deprive students of centuries of cultural experiences. They will then rely on distorted WhatsApp forwards for their history lessons.

      The Mughals like the Delhi Sultans adopted India as their country. Good, bad or ugly, they lived here, married here and died here and weren’t invaders, as is being portrayed. They shaped India’s destiny, and crafted an image of a confident nation and apart from their contribution to India’s art, architecture and culture, they made it the largest economy, controlling 25 per cent of the world’s economy, making it the most sought after nation for trade in Europe.

      Unlike the British, they invested the wealth of India, in India. Their contribution to its history and culture is immense and can’t be negated or ignored.

      On August 15, our Prime Minister will address the nation from the Red Fort in Delhi. The elves didn’t build it. It was built by Shah Jahan, one of history’s most prolific builders. Don’t deprive students of that knowledge.

      Published in DailyO.in

      Share this:

      • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
      • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)

      Related Posts

      Siri the second city of Delhi
      Book and Publication

      Siri the second city of Delhi

      by ranasafvi
      January 23, 2022
      How Bahadur Shah Kept His Hindu And Muslim Subjects United [Book Excerpt]
      Book and Publication

      How Bahadur Shah Kept His Hindu And Muslim Subjects United [Book Excerpt]

      by ranasafvi
      November 24, 2020
      The Shah Burj in Red Fort, Delhi : Then and Now
      Book and Publication

      The Shah Burj in Red Fort, Delhi : Then and Now

      by ranasafvi
      November 9, 2020
      Leave Comment
      Twitter Facebook Instagram Youtube
      Rana Safvi

      Come, explore and fall in love the Beauties of Delhi (Dilli ki Ranaiya’n) and the World with me, Rana Safvi

      I have a masters in medieval history from the prestigious Centre for Advanced Studies, Dept. of History, AMU. A firm believer in our Ganga Jamuni Tehzeeb, I am passionate about gaining and sharing knowledge and these days I am doing it via the social media platform.

      Browse by Category

      Currently Playing

      © 2018 Rana Safvi - A blog Exploring Ganga Jamuni Tehzeeb of India, website handcrafted by Abu Sufiyan.

      No Result
      View All Result
      • Home
      • About
      • Book & Publication
      • Culture & Heritage
        • Our Cultural Heritage
        • Sufi saints
      • Food
      • Hazrat-E-Dilli
      • Rana’s Space
        • Walks & Talks
        • Rana’s Space
        • Sher o Sukhan
      • Travel
      • Contact Me

      © 2018 Rana Safvi - A blog Exploring Ganga Jamuni Tehzeeb of India, website handcrafted by Abu Sufiyan.